Christmas Eve Carryout Menu 2025
Call Now to Reserve Your Order | 330.726.1736
Orders must be placed and paid for by 4 p.m. on Sunday, December 21, 2025.
Pick up on Wednesday, December 24th, from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Salad & Soup:
Blue Wolf Christmas Salad (serves 10-15) $50
House Salad (serves 10) 2 pints of dressing per pan $38
Caesar Salad (serves 10) Dressing on the side $41
Chicken & Peppers Salad (serves 10) 2 pints of dressing per pan $48
Homemade Wedding Soup $15/qt
Soup Du Jour $15/qt
Weekly Rotating Clam Chowder $16/qt
Appetizers:
Battered Smelts $57
Fried Greens & Cheese (serves 10) $57
Famous Jumbo Wolf Wings (50 count) (4 Sauces/per 50) $72
Calamari (serves 10) $52
Assorted Deli Wrap Tray
Choice of 2: (serves 10) Turkey Swiss, Ham Cheddar, or Italian $53
Cheese & Cracker Tray with Honey Dijon (serves 10) $43
Assorted Deli Sandwich Tray
Choice of 2: (serves 10) Turkey Swiss, Ham Cheddar, or Italian $53
Crudité & Dip Veggie Tray (serves 10) Ranch, Bleu Cheese, or French Onion Dip $40
Hummus Tray with Vegetables and Warm Pita (serves 10) Traditional or Red Pepper $46
Stuffed Hot Banana Peppers Sausage, Mozzarella, and Red Sauce $34/dz
Sausage & Greens Stuffed Mushrooms Red Sauce and Parmesan $22/dz
Our Famous Hot Peppers & Oil ……………………………………………………..$8/pt $15/qt
Spinach & Artichoke Dip (serves 10) Tortilla Chips or Warm Pita $48
Shrimp Cocktail (serves 10) $61
Entrées:
Penne Pasta with Meatballs or Sausage (18 Meatballs/Sausage) (serves 10)
(Choice of Sauce: Red, Pomodoro, or Alfredo (+ $8) $46
Chicken Francaise (serves 10) $58
Chicken Marsala Portobello (serves 10) $59
Sausage, Peppers, and Onions over Penne (serves 10) $57
Italian Baked Chicken (serves 10) $54
BBQ Baby Back Ribs (serves 10) (4 bones ea.) $75
Chicken Carbonara over Penne (serves 10) $68
Chicken Parmesan (serves 10) (Choice of Pasta and Sauce) $65
Cheese Ravioli with Meatballs or Sausage (serves 10) (Choice of Sauce) $56
Pan of Meatballs or Italian Sausage with Red Sauce (serves 10) 30 pieces $33
Cavatelli with Meatballs or Sausage (serves 10) $65
North Atlantic Cod (serves 10) $68
Sides:
Buttered Parsley Potatoes (serves 10) $45
Scalloped Potatoes (serves 10) $42
Rice: Pilaf, Wild, or Steamed White (serves 10) $42
Buttered Green Beans (serves 10) $40
Green Beans Amandine (serves 10) $42
Homemade Macaroni & Cheese (serves 10) $39
Mashed Potatoes & Gravy (serves 10) Served with 1qt Gravy
(Choice of chicken, pork, beef, or turkey gravy) $37
Roasted Redskin Potatoes (serves 10) $43
Fresh Warm Dinner Rolls & Whipped Butter $9/dz
Desserts:
Cheesecake Platter (serves 12) (Choice of Topping: Strawberry, Cherry, or Both) $50
Assorted Dessert Platter (serves 12) (A variety of our fresh daily selections) $60
*Reheating instructions included!